Independent candidate signs up to Free Speech Charter

JPCT 120314 S14110982x Nik Butler -photo by Steve Cobb SUS-141203-095711001
JPCT 120314 S14110982x Nik Butler -photo by Steve Cobb SUS-141203-095711001

An Independent candidate in next year’s Horsham District Council elections today signalled his support for the County Times Free Speech Charter.

Nik Butler, who intends to stand in Roffey North, gave his backing to the initiative which was set up in the wake of the secrecy controversy following Christian Mitchell’s deselection as HDC chairman-elect.

Mr Butler said: “I have spoken to two other district councillors about this agreement, since it was announced. One said ‘they would need to discuss it in their group to decide, democratically, if they would sign it’. The other called it ‘ridiculous nonsense and a waste of time and they would not sign it’.

“I cannot imagine where our values are in society where the right to speak clear and free in respect of those you represent is something that can be flippantly dismissed or treated as an option. Party memberships have been flagging or filtering from one to another and politics and voting are more often than not derided. This is not because the electorate have no care for their right to vote; but because their representatives have not shown that they rightly care.

“Despite being an independent candidate I will sign this commitment now and hope that more councillors will join me in commending the value of public opinion before party positions.”

The County Times has written to all 44 district councillors along with the leaders of the political groups at West Sussex County Council inviting them to sign up to a simple statement of intent.

It says: “I undertake to speak, write and vote on behalf of my constituents without fear or favour of party discipline. If I am a member of a political party, I will respect its values and honour its pre-election manifesto pledges - but I will always put first the people I am elected to serve.”

Future candidates of any political party and none are also invited to indicate their support.

Head of News Mark Dunford said: “It is our hope that out of this story we can achieve something that will really help the electorate re-engage with local politics; and the issue of free speech could not be more timely in the year we commemorate the sacrifice of millions of young men in the First World War. Next year, is the 800th anniversary of the Magna Carta, the cornerstone of modern freedom.”

Political editor Joshua Powling added: “The Free Speech Charter is designed to encourage more open debate in council meetings and eliminate the whipping of votes.

“We believe it will help rebuild the public’s trust in local politics as well as engaging more people in the democratic process at council level.

“I know from my own experience of covering council meetings, how dismayed many members of the public are by the predetermined nature of many key debates.

“Planning committees are a notable exception. It would be excellent if all business was transacted with the same spontaneity.

“Turnout at elections has been falling steadily over many years, especially among a younger generation. There is a real sense that much of the ‘cut and thrust’ of political debate has been lost by the single party cabinet system exacerbated by closed private meetings of political groupings where whipped votes have become sadly too familiar on matters of legitimate public interest and concern.”

The Charter was instigated following a whipped vote to deselect Tory vice chairman Mr Mitchell, who said he had been punished for speaking out on behalf of his constituents over plans for massive housing in North Horsham.

Since then, Mr Mitchell has written in this newspaper to describe the secret meetings of his Conservative Group where key decisions are taken in private, and a ‘secret court’ he faced last autumn for raising matters which he believed were in the public interest.